Catch-22

Idiot / Savant

Idiot/Savant is an anonymous blogger living in exile.  He blogs about human rights, international affairs, and politics from a left - liberal perspective. Check out his blog

A couple of months ago, the Greens highlighted the persistent gender pay gap, and pushed for a law change to help close it by giving employees greater access to pay information. The government claimed that this wasn't necessary, as employees suspecting gender discrimination could simply ask for a labour inspector to investigate the issue on their behalf (and therefore any discrimination is the fault of women, for not acting to enforce their rights in this way). So, the Greens took them at their word, and got 261 workers in 18 workplaces across the country to ask for exactly such an investigation into their local workplace. You'll never guess what the result was:

Catch-22

Kelly says some 261 workers in 18 workplaces nationwide wrote to the labour inspectors, as the minister had suggested, seeking an investigation into their pay. They were told they need evidence that a pay gap exists before the inspectors can investigate.

So, in order to get evidence that a gender pay gap exists, you need evidence that a gender pay gap exists. Its a classic catch-22. Meanwhile, discrimination continues, and sexist employers laugh all the way to the bank.

Someone really needs to ask Kate Wilkinson if she's happy with this situation, and what (if anything) she's going to do about it. But I expect that as with Paula Bennett and 150 dead children a year from child poverty, she'll be "unavailable for comment".

 
Sort by
  • Wice says
    I guess it's a matter of referring back the original comment. i.e. that "...employees SUSPECTING gender discrimination could simply ask for a labour inspector to investigate the issue on their behalf".

    I don't know who said this, or in what context, but surely, if this is officially what was said, then there would be a definite argument that suspicion rather than evidence is all that is needed to get an investigation under way.
  • shiny says
    the circle of life...if it's not officially documented then politicians than say whatever they like...bit like the pre-election promises that come forth so readily to sway us gullible voters.

    i think that the whole pay equity thing, is very difficult to provide substantial argument for...for example with an employee who has been loyal to a company, will often find equity with a new job (as market rates will determine pay rate) yet if the company has had very few and little pay increases over the years then a gap will typically exist regardless of gender. basically if you're feeling screwed then you probably are and seek employment elsewhere imho

Post your comment

Want to have your say?

It's quick, easy and 100% free.

  •  

Features

  • Cocktails, Shots, & Drink Recipes Cocktails, Shots, & Drink Recipes

    Drink in style.

  • Funny Jokes Funny Jokes

    Updated daily for your twisted enjoyment...

  • Daily Video Daily Video

    Check out today's videos, they take up our broadband bandwidth but these Youtube clips are particularly worth it!

  • NZ Daily Deal Aggregator NZ Daily Deal Aggregator

    Save time - saving money. The best daily deals from around New Zealand pulled together onto one page & updated every 10 minutes.

  • Best Sex Positions Best Sex Positions

    Spice up your love life with Get Frank's list of best sex positions to wake the neighbours!

Competitions

Endorsed Events